The grey mouse is happier than you
Emily, be serious, Charlotte eyed her old cotton dress as if it was a battered relic rescued from a forgotten attic. Do you really wear that scruffy thing? Around your husband?
Emily tugged absently at the hem. The dress was worn soft by years of wash and sun.
I like it…
Like it, she says… You like all sorts of odd bits, chimed in Alice, her face lit by the bluish glow of her phone. Sitting at home, making stews, crocheting doilies. Do you even realise youth doesnt last forever? You ought to live, not simply exist.
Charlotte nodded keenly, her new earrings fat gleaming hoops swinging with each dramatic gesture:
Henry and I went to that new place in Soho last night. Divine! I suppose you fried up potatoes. Again.
Emily had fried them. With mushrooms, just as William liked. He came home exhausted, ate two helpings, and dozed off against her shoulder in front of the telly. Emily hadnt told anyone. Why bother? Her friends would never understand.
Once, all three friends married within months of each other. Emily remembered that year: her quiet registry service, Charlottes lavish affair with live band and fireworks, then Alices celebration where every guest received a personalized party favour. Even then, Emily noticed the exchanged glances when she mentioned honeymoon plans a week at Williams parents cottage in Norfolk. Charlotte snorted into her prosecco, and Alice rolled her eyes so clearly you could almost hear it.
The subtle jabs became a constant background hum; Emily learnt to tune them out, though every time something ached quietly inside.
Charlotte swept into every room, impossible to ignore laughter booming, arms wide, endless tales of who said what and who looked at whom. Her flat with Henry buzzed like Piccadilly Circus: friends, workmates, stray acquaintances drifting in and out, leaving behind smudged wine glasses and ruby stains on the pale rug.
Well have about twenty over Saturday, Charlotte announced down the line. Come round! Henrys doing a roast.
Emily politely turned her down. William craved silence after his week, not strangers ransacking the kitchen.
So keep hiding in your mousehole, Charlotte sighed, her voice flickering with something like pity.
At first, Henry played along. Set the table, joked with guests, swept up the aftermath. Emily glimpsed him at the rare parties she braved: tired eyes, taut smile, mechanical motions. He filled glasses, laughed at cues, but his gaze drifted further away every time.
Henry, you look sour, Charlotte tweaked his cheek in front of everyone. Smile, else theyll think I starve you.
Henry smiled dutifully. Everyone laughed. Emily wondered how long a mask can be worn before it bonds to your skin, or before youd tear it off, flesh and all.
Ten years later, the mask split. Henry left Charlotte for a quiet woman in accounts who, rumour had it, brought him home-baked pies for lunch and never raised her voice. Charlotte learned last, even as whispers whipped round the whole office for weeks.
Hes left me, Charlotte sobbed into the phone, clattering something in the background. Ungrateful wretch! I gave him my best years. And hes abandoned me!
Emily listened. What could she say? That Henry spent ten years falling asleep to other peoples laughter, waking to voices not his own? That a house cant be all endless celebration?
After the divorce, it turned out the flat was mortgaged to the hilt and the debts couldve bought a small car. Charlotte was left alone, untangling the financial mess her loud laughter faded to something thin and lonely.
Meanwhile Alice was building her own shiny empire. Her Facebook was cluttered with photos: restaurants, boutiques, holidays by the sea. Perfect makeup and captions about bliss and gratitude to the universe. Her husband Daniel faded into the background a blurred silhouette sustaining it all.
Look at this, Alice shoved her phone under Emilys nose. Sophies husband got her a necklace from Tiffany. And mine? Another silly trinket.
Maybe he prefers choosing himself?
Alice gave Emily a look as if shed spoken Greek:
No thanks. I texted him a list. He can pick from that.
Emily kept quiet. Yesterday William had found her a book she wanted, hunted it down in a little independent shop near the station, wrapped it in brown paper, all himself. Emily didnt mention it Alice would only snigger at such poverty.
For five years Daniel met every expectation. Overtime, extra shifts, stretching for the finish line Alice kept raising out of reach. Then he met a girl at the bookstore divorced, a child in tow, no manicured nails or designer bags. She looked at him as though he was already enough. No requirements. No checklist.
Their split was quick and messy. Alice demanded everything, got half legal not generous. By then, the family accounts had been cleaned bare: spa subscriptions, beauty treatments, relentless shopping trips. Not a penny saved.
How am I supposed to live? Alice wept in a café, streaking mascara over coffees she couldnt afford. On what?
Emily drank her tea and realised: for all the years, Alice never asked how Emily lived, how William was, if their health was fine. Her world had circled a single sun herself.
Both friends ended up in the same boat: no husbands, no money, no familiar shiny routines. Charlotte took another job to chip away at her loans. Alice moved into a smaller flat and stopped posting photos.
Emilys days went on much the same. She cooked William his suppers, asked about his work, listened to tangled tales of supplier mishaps and tricky negotiations. No demands, no scenes, no weighing her life against some glossy ideal. She was there: solid as the house walls, warm as lamplight in a kitchen window.
William noticed. One night he came home carrying a folder and laid it on the table.
Whats this?
Half the business. Yours now.
Emily stared at the papers, afraid to touch.
Why?
Because you earned it. Because I want you safe. Because none of this would exist without you.
A year later, he bought her a flat bright, roomy, huge windows. Signed it in her name. Emily cried into his shoulder, and William stroked her hair, calling her his treasure, his quiet port in a storm.
Old friends started popping round more often. First rarely, then more and more. They sat on the new sofa, fingered the silk pillows, studied the art on the walls. Emily saw it in their faces: confusion, unease, half-hidden envy.
Wheres all this come from? Charlotte surveyed the sitting room.
William gave it to me.
Justgave it?
Just because.
Charlotte and Alice exchanged glances. Emily refilled their tea and said nothing.
One visit, Charlotte finally snapped. She thumped down her cup, splashing coffee over the saucer and burst out:
Tell me why. Why did we lose everything and you, you grey mouse, keep on being happy?
A hush settled over the cake plates. Alice stared out the window, pretending not to care, fingers fidgeting with a tacky ring instead of diamond.
Emily could have answered. She could have spoken about patience. About noticing tiny things. About how true happiness in marriage isnt loud parties, but daily, tender graft. About how to love is to listen, see, protect. Not demand, but give.
But why bother? For twenty years the advice had been live larger and dont be dull. For twenty years no one saw her, just the background furniture to their noisy dramas.
Maybe Im just lucky, Emily smiled.
After that, the visits petered out. Finally stopped altogether. Jealousy overpowered old friendship, shared history, common sense. Easier to turn away than admit they’d been wrong.
Emily didnt grieve. Oddly, the absence filled up with gentle, clear peace as if shed finally kicked off too-tight shoes, finally breathing free.
Another ten years passed. Emily turned fifty-four, life humming gently. Grown-up children, a grandson, William still bringing her books in brown paper. By chance, she heard from an old acquaintance that Charlotte never remarried, still worked two jobs, always complaining of her health. Alice had tried three new men, but every relationship crumbled under the same storm of grievances and demands.
Emily listened, without gloating. She simply thought how sometimes the grey mice find real happiness: quiet, invisible outside, priceless inside.
She switched off her phone and went to prepare supper. William had promised to come home early and requested, of course, fried potatoes with mushrooms.







